We DESPERATELY need coins, currency, and bullion to fill new orders. We have suspended all sales until we restock!

Questions & Answers

Questions about coins and currency? Have them answered by Marc Rosner, a true numismatist! See what others have asked about their collections, and then get some information on your own collection.

Q. Included in a modest coin collection I inherited is an uncirculated silver ...

Dear Michael,

That's like asking a dentist the safe way to fill your own cavity. Odds are an untrained person will do irreversible damage. If the "green" corrosion is very light it may be salvageable. If it's a valuable piece. I offer conservation services that may be worth it. To illustrate: I was doing an appraisal for a lawyer in Br...

Asked by Michael B. on Nov 16, 2018

Q. Hello. I am a newly retired health care professional. I am looking for help...

Dear Arnold, 

Here is my honest opinion, borne out of experience. As much as I love coins and bullion, I would not advise you to "stack" silver or other precious metals for a number of reasons. Silver and gold are not great long term investments, unless you happen to time things right. They don't go perpetually up, they wander wit...

Asked by Arnold S. on Nov 16, 2018

Q. Marc. Thank you for the advise. I would like to work with you. I am conside...

Silver, as an investment, wanders in value. Buy it if it makes you happy.

Asked by Arnold on Nov 16, 2018

Q. Marc. Thank you for the advise. I would like to work with you. I am conside...

Buy it if it makes you happy!

Asked by Arnold on Nov 16, 2018

Q. Marc. Thank you for the advise. I would like to work with you. I am conside...

These are worth their weight in silver, about $17.50 per ounce today. I advise you buy it to enjoy it, not as an investment.

Asked by Arnold on Nov 16, 2018

Q. I am interested in the currency used in the Hudson Valley between 1650 and ...

I usually keep such notes for my own collection. I have a nice Ballston Spa note for $250, small size; and some more common ones from New York City. You should read about obsolete currency, and check out the auction archives of Heritage Currency for local banks.

Asked by Steve Wood on Nov 16, 2018

Q. We're cleaning out my mom's house and finding more and more stuff. Do you h...

Eughan, your situation is more common than you may realize and one of our specialties. Check EVERYWHERE, every file folder could contain currency, the attic floorboards could be covering silver and gold. My mother found diamonds in my grandmother's condo, they were inside a shirt that was sealed in the original Macy's package like new. I can als...

Asked by Eughan Highsmith on Nov 16, 2018

Q. Is it true that if you clean your old coin it loses its value?

The short answer is yes. Unless you are trained to do it, cleaning a coin will remove the oxidation, or "toning," and render it much lower in value. Once that's done, trying to fix it will only make things worse. A qualified numismatist may know how to clean off dirt and grease and restore a coin to its original beauty; but like a fine piece of ...

Asked by Andrei Hnedchyk on Nov 16, 2018

Q. I’m just wondering I have so many old coins I can’t upload them all is ther...

Of course!  Call me at 914-649-3317 I can figure out all sorts of things with you over the phone. --Marc

Asked by John vega on Nov 16, 2018

Q. Hi Marc, My father gave me his Roman coin collection and I was wondering...

First, don't clean anything. Keep the coins stored in a cool, dark, dry place. We can do an appraisal when you're ready!

Marc

Asked by Chip Gullenberg on Nov 16, 2018

Q. Hi Marc, My father gave me his Roman coin collection and I was wondering...

I can appraise or purchase. Often these have nominal value; sometimes more. Marc 914-649-3317. 

Asked by Chip Gullenberg on Nov 16, 2018

Q. I have silver libertys I would like to liquidate, can I bring them all with...

We can lock in a rate in advance, or trade based upon the current spot price. Call me at 9147-649-3317.

Asked by Marisa serbinov on Nov 16, 2018

Q. I have a few 1943 wheat pennys that I have collected and I think one of the...

They are all steel. Some may look like they are a different metal because of oxidation. We buy these for 1.5 cents apiece, and sell them for 2 cents. We can pay more for a large number, such as ten or more rolls ($5 face value).

Asked by Ivette castillo on Nov 16, 2018

Q. Do you appraise stamps? Do you buy stamps?

Yes. But Stamps rarely have value.  

Marc

 914-649-3317

Asked by Jordan Ellsworth on Nov 16, 2018

Q. Hi, is it true that a single 1943 penny is worth many thousands of dollars?...

This is possibly the most common question we get asked. Your 1943 cent (Britain has pennies, not us!) is worth a cent. The confusion arises from the fact that these cents were made out of zinc-coated steel. While there are a few copper 1943 cents (and a few steel 1944's) out there, I'm confident you don't have one. You'll know because you can li...

Asked by Craig on Nov 16, 2018

Q. Hi, Marc. I like your website. I have a 1912 gold sovereign coin. I think i...

This depends on the grade and mint Mark, I have to see them. Also a full sovereign and a half sovereign they look exactly the same and so it should be weighed or measured. An uncirculated Australia sovereign of that date can retail for &400. A worn common one scraps at $250. That's your range. It was made as a bullion product and i...

Asked by Andres on Nov 16, 2018

Q. Is my 1878 Morgan Silver Dollar worth $5,000?

Odds are it's worth $15-20. The U.S. government made millions more silver dollars than were ever needed because of a powerful silver lobby. Hundreds of thousands have been found in modern times in uncirculated bank bags. Your early dollar may look great, but the dies were sharp back then and many people set them aside. It's harder to find a dime...

Asked by Alyssa on Nov 16, 2018

Q. I found a jar of old coins. Which are silver?

All dimes, quarters, half dollars, and dollars minted 1964 and earlier. Many were set aside from circulation around that time, and as of today (March 13, 2018) they are worth about twelve times face value. So a dime is worth $1.20 in silver.

Asked by Carlos on Nov 16, 2018

Q. I have a sterling silver flatware I'm thinking of selling. I have a 4 set ...

You will get about the same either way. We pay more than the melters because we have retail clients. 

Marc

Asked by cathy ashe on Nov 16, 2018

Q. Value of Kenny half dollars

Regular issue Kennedy half dollars, at today’s silver price, are worth $6 for 1964 specimens; $2.50 for 1965-1970; and half a dollar thereafter. 

Asked by E Smith on Nov 16, 2018

Q. Dear Michael, Good afternoon! I have (5) silver dollars. One 1883-S , two...

Susan, your half dollars are probably worth $12-15. If the 1921s are the newer style Peace Dollar, they are somewhat more. The paper currency and cents are probably so close to face value you should give them to kids. Perhaps you can get them off the smart phone for a minute and develop a hobby. The other things are probably worth more for their...

Asked by Susan Brownell on Nov 16, 2018


Ask Your Own Question!