Online Appraisal
D. Ungraded: 1893 Quarter, 1907 Quarter, 1892 Dime, 1893-S Dime, 1857 Half Dime, 1872 Dime, 1914-D Quarter, 1901 Dime, 1892 Half Dollar, 1858 Dime, 1871 Half Dime, 1862 Half Dime, 1893 Half Dollar, 1857 Dime, 1854 Dime Graded: AU 53 Details: Damaged 1873-S Quarter, EF 45 Details: Cleaned 1877-S Quarter, G4 1907-D Half Dollar, VF25 1857 Quarter, G4 1912 Half Dollar, F12 1897 Half Dollar, VF35 Details: Cleaned, Scratched 1861 Quarter, F12 1915-S Half Dollar, AU50 Details: Cleaned 1901-O Dime, EF40 Details: Seated Damaged 1872 Half Dime, F15 Details: Corroded, Tooled 1833 Half Dime, VF35 Details: Heavily Corroded 1872 Half Dollar, F15 Details: Scratched, Corroded, Cleaned 1856 Quarter
Asked on Dec 21, 2025
I guess you missed the part where we state, right before you click “submit,” that we offer one or two complimentary appraisals per day. But let me give you the executive summary on your coins. Someone, and forgive my candor if I’m mistaken but I’m guessing it’s you, made the mistake of paying to certify them, which was a great expense relative to their value. If you go to Coinflation.com you’ll see their melt value is about 40-50 times face value. For instance, the dimes have $4 of silver, and the quarters, $10. Now you might think these are old and collectible, and they are, but the grades are low and the “details” pieces are problem coins with damage. They are more common than you might think. So if you double those numbers you’ll get a rough idea of the retail value. I only surveyed them quickly but suspect close study will verify that. Feel free to call me if you have any questions. Marc
SUBMIT AN ITEM FOR FREE APPRAISAL
We kindly ask you to limit your request to ONE item, preferably with images of both sides. We specialize in items that are older and of some historic importance. Please include photos of both sides if possible.
We may use your appraisal on our site as reference for others with the same item(s). We'll never display your personal information and will remove all sensitive information from your submission. Please contact us for a private appraisal. View our privacy policy.
Most inquiries we get are about circulated coins made after 1971, and/or coins where people mistake post-mint damage and wear for "errors". You can expect us to affirm these are face value. We ask that before you write and submit such questions, to PLEASE first read through our existing postings and our "what it's worth" primers.
Photo Criteria: Acceptable photo formats are gif, jpg, and png and no larger than 15 MB. If you are using an iPhone, make sure that the photo is not set to LIVE, as this format will be not be uploaded.