Online Appraisal
D. Hey I’m a little far from you guys. Just curious on what you guys would offer for this in icg. Thanks.
Asked on Feb 24, 2026
I'd probably be at $1. Now I realize Mr. Hutto might be an important person to some and the Greysheet value of this coin in this grade is supposed to be $900, but I can't buy into the hype over collectible slabs and high grade moderns. You're supposed to buy the coin and not the holder. ICG is in my mind a fine company but doesn't command the respect of NGC and PCGS. Many millions of this coin were minted and there have to be tons of high grade ones out there in mint sets. I apologize if this isn't the answer you want to hear, but Google "Tulip mania" if you want to know the likely future of speculative coin investing.
SUBMIT AN ITEM FOR FREE APPRAISAL
We kindly ask you to limit your request to ONE item, preferably with images of both sides. We specialize in items that are older and of some historic importance. Please include photos of both sides if possible.
We may use your appraisal on our site as reference for others with the same item(s). We'll never display your personal information and will remove all sensitive information from your submission. Please contact us for a private appraisal. View our privacy policy.
Most inquiries we get are about circulated coins made after 1971, and/or coins where people mistake post-mint damage and wear for "errors". You can expect us to affirm these are face value. We ask that before you write and submit such questions, to PLEASE first read through our existing postings and our "what it's worth" primers.
Photo Criteria: Acceptable photo formats are gif, jpg, and png and no larger than 15 MB. If you are using an iPhone, make sure that the photo is not set to LIVE, as this format will be not be uploaded.